Market Snapshot:
The numbers are in for the Toronto housing market and to nobody’s surprise, fewer properties sold than last August and the average price for all housing types were also down. As a rule, August is almost always one of the slowest months of the year so this isn’t groundbreaking news. I was hoping that there might be a turnaround in September, but unfortunately, much of the market is still feeling sluggish.
Echoes of the late ‘80s??
I don’t think we’re anywhere close to that yet but, depending on the housing type, it might feel that way to some. Way back then, there was an overall malaise to the market in general. Interest rates hovered at about 10% (unfathomable now!) and inventory levels were very high. The average days on market soared and nothing was selling, so sellers were dropping their prices like a rock. We’re not there in our overall market, but the sense of uncertainty and the wait and see attitude from buyers is familiar, especially in the condo market.
Why is this happening?
The media has been reporting a slight increase in mortgage defaults, but I believe (and this is backed by CTV) that some are secondary and investment properties. I imagine that investors are the ones defaulting because it’s difficult to rent an investment property where the rent covers today’s rates and price points, and they are having trouble selling their units because there’s so much inventory. People that live in their homes have a higher incentive to keep paying their mortgage as best they can. Investors are more likely to walk away and take the loss if pushed to that point.
Everyday expenses - groceries, utilities, gas - are eating into budgets. Even if people qualify for a mortgage, many feel stretched and hesitant to take on more debt.
When the news is full of economic warnings, international conflicts, and shifting government policies, it’s no wonder people hit pause. Big moves feel risky when the future is so unpredictable.
Rate cuts aren’t enough
With the recent Bank of Canada rate decrease, interest rates are at the lowest they’ve been in three years. However, I don’t see anything on the horizon that’s going to change buyer sentiment any time soon unless we get back down the interest rates we had during the pandemic, and I don’t foresee that happening.
In addition to that, even if the prime rate decreases, the big banks aren’t adjusting their fixed mortgage rates so there really isn’t much of a savings being felt. Lowering the prime rate really only benefits those with variable mortgages or lines of credit.
Short-term outlook
My prediction is that the market will remain stagnant for a while. Investors who can’t sell are renting out their units for less as the rental market becomes flooded, which means it’s a good time to be a renter… and with the continued sense of market unpredictability, some may feel that renting is a safer bet for their situation at this time.
My advice for sellers
Sellers will continue to face increased competition. In an up-market, every sale sets a new precedent at a higher price. In today’s market, precedents are still being set - but in the opposite direction.
If there are multiple listings on your street or in your building, your goal should be to sell first out of all of them. That requires standing out, both in presentation and in price. An attractive price often means going lower than you’d like, but that’s the reality we’re facing. You can list at any number you choose, but pricing too high only guarantees your property will be overlooked while someone else sets the benchmark.
My advice for buyers
The leverage you have as a buyer right now is fantastic, regardless of whether a seller is willing to accept an offer, they’re willing to negotiate. You may end up paying a little more now than if you hold off and buy in a year, but if you’re secure in your finances and living in a space that no longer suits your needs and moving into a different space would mean a better quality of life, it’s something to strongly consider.
My prediction for the September numbers?
We will see a huge uptick in the number of new listings. There are over 11,900 listings currently available. I don’t think we’ll see a significant number of sales. Of course there will be sales but prices overall will also/probably continue to slowly soften.
The bottom line
Waiting and watching can cost you - or it can set you up for the right move. If you’re unsure which way to lean, reach out today and we’ll walk through your options together.